“I opened a brokerage app six months ago with $500. I check it maybe fifteen times a day, I’ve made something like forty trades, and I’m down a little. Is that normal, or is the app doing something to me?”
It’s a fair question, and the honest answer is: a bit of both. Checking often and trading often are common habits for new investors. But the apps people use to invest are built by product teams whose jobs include getting you to open the app more. Some of the features that make investing feel easy also make it feel like a game, and games are designed to be played a lot. Investing, for most people, works better when you barely touch it.
Here’s how those design choices work, why they push beginners in the wrong direction, and what you can change in your settings today.
The features regulators started calling “digital engagement practices”
In 2021, after a wave of new retail traders arrived during the pandemic, the Securities and Exchange Commission asked the public for comment on what it called digital engagement practices: the prompts, rewards and visual cues that brokerage apps use to shape behavior. A later SEC rule proposal on the topic was withdrawn in 2025, so there is no specific federal rule banning these features. State regulators have also taken an interest; Massachusetts securities regulators brought a case against one popular app over gamified design, which settled in 2024.
The features that drew attention tend to fall into a few groups:
- Celebrations. Confetti, animations or badges after a trade. The reward comes from the act of trading, not from whether the trade was a good idea.
- Streaks and milestones. “You’ve invested 5 days in a row.” A streak turns a long-term activity into a daily one.
- Push notifications about price moves. “Your stock is up 6% today.” Alerts like this invite you to act on a single day’s noise.
- Top-movers and “most popular” lists. These put the most volatile names front and center, which is the opposite of what a beginner usually needs to look at.
- Low-friction access to riskier products. Options, margin and crypto sometimes sit one or two taps away from the main buy button, with approval flows that take minutes.
- Free stock lotteries and referral rewards. Fun, harmless in small amounts, but they frame the account as a place to win things.
Why more trades usually means worse results
Trading itself isn’t the problem. The problem is that each trade is a decision, and most quick decisions made on a phone screen are reactions to recent price movement. A stock that jumped this morning feels like it’s “going somewhere.” A fund that dipped feels broken. Acting on those feelings tends to mean buying after a rise and selling after a fall, which is how people end up behind the very investments they owned.
There are mechanical costs too, even when there’s no commission:
- Spreads. The gap between the buy price and the sell price is small on big stocks and wide on thinly traded ones. Trade forty times and those small gaps add up.
- Taxes. In a regular taxable account, gains on anything held a year or less are taxed as short-term gains, at the same rate as your paycheck. Frequent trading turns potential long-term gains into short-term ones.
- Wash sale complications. Sell at a loss and buy the same thing back within 30 days, and the loss gets deferred. Frequent traders trip over this without realizing it until tax forms arrive.
Then there’s the time cost. Fifteen check-ins a day is a habit loop, and it pulls attention toward the least useful information available: what your account did in the last hour.
The options and margin nudge
The most expensive version of this problem is when an app’s flow makes options or margin feel like the natural next step. Options can lose 100% of what you put in, quickly, and some strategies can lose more. Margin means borrowing against your account, which magnifies losses as well as gains. Neither is a beginner tool. If you’re curious about how options work before you ever enable them, read our explainer on options trading before you try it, and see FINRA’s overview of options for the regulator’s description of the risks.
Settings that take the game out of the app
Most brokerage apps let you dial down the engagement features. Menus differ, but look for these:
- Turn off price-movement notifications. Keep alerts for deposits, executed orders and security events. Drop alerts for “your stock moved X%.”
- Hide the top-movers or trending lists if the app allows it, or simply stop opening that tab.
- Switch the home screen to show total balance rather than today’s gain or loss, if that option exists. Some apps let you hide the daily change.
- Decline options and margin approval. If you already enabled them and don’t use them, many apps let you downgrade your account or turn off margin.
- Set up automatic recurring investments into a broad fund. A recurring buy does the work so you don’t have to make a fresh decision each week.
- Move the app off your home screen. Low-tech, but it works. Put it in a folder two swipes away.
None of these change what you own. They change how often you’re asked to decide something, which matters more than people expect.
A simple rule for the money you want to play with
Wanting to pick a few stocks or follow a hot name is normal, and banning it entirely usually doesn’t stick. A more durable approach: set aside a small, fixed slice of your investing money, often something like 5% or less, for picks and experiments. Everything else goes into a diversified fund on autopilot. When the play money is gone, it’s gone, and you don’t top it up from the core. We go deeper on this idea in our piece on meme stocks and hype cycles.
What to do this week
- Count your trades from the last three months. Most brokerage apps show order history. Write the number down.
- Open notification settings and turn off every price alert.
- Check whether options or margin are enabled on your account. If you didn’t mean to have them, turn them off.
- Pick one broad index fund and set up an automatic weekly or monthly buy, even a small one.
- Decide on your play-money slice in dollars, not a vague feeling, and write it somewhere you’ll see it.
Common questions
Is it bad to have a commission-free app at all?
No. Commission-free trading genuinely lowers costs, and plenty of long-term investors use these apps. The tool is fine; the trouble is letting its default settings decide how often you trade.
How often should a beginner check their investments?
There’s no official number, but for long-term money, monthly or even quarterly is plenty. A useful check is: would anything you see today change what you do? If not, you probably didn’t need to look.
Do free stock rewards come with strings?
Usually the strings are small: you might need to hold the shares for a set period before selling, and the stock counts as income for tax purposes in some cases. Read the promotion terms before you assume it’s a pure gift.
What if I already lost money overtrading?
Losses in a taxable account can offset gains and, within limits, some ordinary income, so they aren’t wasted on your tax return. More useful, though, is treating them as the price of learning which habits to drop. Stop the bleeding first, then automate.



