Diversification for Beginners: Why One Fund Can Hold Thousands of Companies

2 weeks ago

By admin

The rule is simple: don’t let any single company be able to sink your savings. Diversification means spreading money across many investments so that when one does badly, which some always will, the damage is small. For a beginner, the easiest way to follow that rule is not to buy a lot of individual stocks. It’s to buy one broad fund that already owns hundreds or thousands of them.

Key takeaways

Three favorite stocks vs. one broad fund

Take a hypothetical new investor with $3,000. Option A: split it evenly among three companies she likes and uses every day, $1,000 each. Option B: put all $3,000 into a fund that tracks the total U.S. stock market.

Now imagine one of her three companies has a terrible year: an accounting problem, a failed product, a lawsuit. Its stock falls 60%. Here’s how that one event hits each option:

Option A: three stocks Option B: total-market fund
Weight of the troubled company 33% Likely well under 1%, unless it’s one of the very largest firms
Loss from that company alone $600, or 20% of the account A few dollars, possibly cents
What drives results Three companies’ news The combined performance of thousands of businesses
Research needed Ongoing, for each company Minimal

The flip side is real too. If one of her three picks triples, Option A wins big. Concentration cuts both ways. But for most beginners the downside matters more: a 20% hit from one bad headline is the kind of thing that makes people quit investing altogether.

How one fund holds thousands of companies

A mutual fund or exchange-traded fund (ETF) pools money from many investors and buys a basket of securities. An index fund buys the basket defined by a particular index. A few common ones:

When you buy one share of such a fund, you own a tiny slice of every company in it. You don’t need $3 million to own 3,000 stocks; the fund handles that, and you pay for it through an annual expense ratio. At large providers, broad index funds often charge a small fraction of a percent per year. Vanguard is one well-known example of an index fund provider; many brokerages offer comparable funds. If terms like “ETF” or “expense ratio” are new, our investing vocabulary starter covers them.

One wrinkle: the big names weigh more

Most broad index funds are “market-cap weighted,” meaning bigger companies take up a larger share. In recent years a handful of giant tech-related companies have made up a large portion of the S&P 500. That’s still far more spread out than owning three stocks, but it’s worth knowing that a total-market fund isn’t perfectly evenly divided among its holdings.

What diversification can’t do

Diversification protects you from company-specific risk: one firm’s bad luck or bad management. It doesn’t protect you from market risk, the kind that comes from recessions, interest rate shocks or a broad sell-off. In 2008 and again in 2022, broad stock funds fell along with nearly everything else.

That’s why a second layer exists: spreading money across different types of assets, such as stocks, bonds and cash. The SEC’s Investor.gov page on asset allocation and diversification explains how the two ideas fit together. How much you hold in each depends on your timeline and comfort with swings, which we cover in figuring out your risk tolerance.

False diversification to watch for

Some portfolios look spread out but aren’t:

Frequently asked questions

Is one fund really enough?

For many beginners, one broad fund is a solid starting point. Some people pair a U.S. total-market fund with an international fund, or use a target-date fund that bundles stocks and bonds into a single holding and adjusts the mix over time.

Can I still own a few individual stocks?

Sure. A common approach is to keep the core of your money in broad funds and limit individual picks to a small slice. Our piece on meme stocks walks through how to fence off that slice.

Does diversifying mean lower returns?

It means you’ll get roughly the market’s return, minus a small fee, rather than the return of your best or worst pick. You give up the chance of a lottery-style win in exchange for avoiding a wipeout, and many investors who try to pick winners end up trailing the broad market anyway.

How many individual stocks would I need to be diversified?

There’s no exact number, and estimates vary, but it takes far more than a handful spread across different industries. Buying and tracking that many companies yourself is a lot of work, which is exactly the problem index funds solve.

What to do this week

About the Author

Author

Trending Articles: